Yes Ohya is good

Meh overall for me. But still a better pairing than someone like Ann.

By "Meh" TogoSystem means "Actually best totally"

But still a better pairing than someone like Ann. Ohya has more character development then Ann.

No, I mean not particularly likable, romantically compatible, or even very useful in the game itself.

One of the better character designs, an actually good confidant once you get into it. But it's the single most useless perk in the entire game and I hope Atlus either changes it or adds something else to her as well in the remake.

I'll admit to even myself that my Confidant Bonuses are not the best. But they can be a useful safety net for some players, or just handy for those who are impatient sometimes! I'd also argue that just as many perks could be considered useless. In my playthrough, I still got more use out of Ohy- er, my own, perks than Iwai or Shinya's. Really whether a bonus is useless or useful is all down to perspective and how you play the game. Ohya being best girl is fact though, perspective be damned.

Yeah the only time in the entire game I played badly enough to warrant being thrown out was the heist for Futaba. And since that's a heist, I can't be thrown out. And I'm guessing that's why Atlus designed such a horrible stretch of enemies trying to get the jump on you.

She does at least play probably the biggest role of all confidants at the end though, story wise. I don't think she's unattractive either, apart from how she probably reeks of booze or smokes, but come on, Hifumi Togo clearly has everything going for her instead. Looks, personality AND skills. The best in the game for me.

See, here's an example of different perspectives in action. TogoSystem likes Hifumi Togo and I think she's one of the worst characters in the game.

Total opposites in that regard. I don't think Ohya is a bad character, but she's barely utilized in the game. She stopped being interesting for me past the 'fake dating'. I wanted to see more clever conniving like that or public charades with her, but I don't think she ever left the bar after that. Built that up and didn't do anything.

Ohya actually becomes useful when you are playing P5 on NG+. I abused her perks by speedrunning through the palaces so that I can focus on getting the platinum trophy quicker. In reality, Iwai has the most useless perks out of all of them. He can only mod your guns, but cannot mod them for you if they have any special effects on them already.

Not to mention his perks are only really useful a little bit in a second run. In the first run his Confidant unlocks so late into the game for most people that unless you start binging his Confidant, he can only mod guns that the player would have sold a long fucking time ago for being too weak.

Ohya actually becomes useful when you are playing P5 on NG+. I abused her perks by speedrunning through the palaces so that I can focus on getting the platinum trophy quicker. In reality, Iwai has the most useless perks out of all of them. He can only mod your guns, but cannot mod them for you if they have any special effects on them already. There's items for that. I've never utilized or even noticed her abilities. Nor do I care about things like getting trophies. I've used Iwai many times. The discount from him allowed me to save a lot of money. Not that useful, sure, but not worthless either. Also, I don't think they utilized Ohya properly in most of her ranks. Didn't have that issue with anyone else.