Welcome to Phansite archive (beta)
You'll find here all archived threads from the Phansite forum.
Soundtrack-wise P3 vs P4 vs P5
How would you rank these?
It's diffucult for me because all of them have great soundtracks. I guess I liked P3 ost for battle themes, P4 for slice of life moments songs, and P5 has some of the best dungeon music and miscellaneous music (like Airsoft theme etc)
Also, I know I didn't include P1 and P2 but if you wanna feel free to put them in your list as well. Some of the P2 tracks rock but I didn't play enough to judge whole ost.
I would say that it goes P5 > P4 = P3 for me. I enjoy all the soundtracks, but P5's is most definitely the best.
i wish P5 had more diverse music to play during the daily lives instead of one song you hear in school and the same song that plays every day and they only make it different by adding lyrics to it when it hits the evening. As good as I think it is the best, I just expected more from this. Thats about it really. I love every other song in the game a lot though.
I enjoy P5's battle and dungeon music more, but I miss P4's daily music. YOUR AFFECTION~ YOUR AFFECTION~
P5 > P3 > P4. Take nothing from P4s soundtrack though, it just had more mehs than hits for me. Let's Go to the Beach was great; I could see a vocal track made from it.
ok but School Days.
P5 > P3 > P4

P5 has the best songs, IMO, that really pull you in and keep your attention.

P3 has subtle music to try and float the theme. A lot of it is forgettable, but it still compliments events quite well.

P4 tried too hard to be jpop. I really like jpop but I don't think it had a place in this game.
P5 had the best songs by far
P3 had some good music.

P4 had some good music.

But P5 definitely has the best music to date imho.
P5 soundtrack was really solid overall. I'm really attached to the daily life music from p4 tho
All Persona games have amazing soundtracks. Can't wait to get the P1
and P2 DLC. I need Lone Prayer back in my life.
P5 = or > P3 > P4
All the songs are good in all of them really. I think it's more of a "does the soundtrack fit the game more?" aspect I like to look at. In that sense, I definitely feel P5's soundtrack fits in the best with its game in comparison to P4 and P3. It really tied the whole being a stylish thief with amazing stylish music. P3 had a lot of tracks that made Tatsumi Port Island feel like a bustling city but P4's music tried to make Inaba feel exciting which conflicted with how Inaba actually is tbh. So I'd rank it P5 > P3 > P4
P3 > P4 > P5

P5 has some amazing dungeon music, but most of the battle music is just good, not great. I also wasn't a big fan of the day to day tracks. They were good at first, but I found they sounded repetitive a lot quicker than either 3 or 4.

4 has a great overall soundtrack that's more listenable on its own, but I have to rank 3 above both because of how unique and weird it is. I'll never forget the first time Deep Breath Deep Breath played in game. Also, 3 has Battle for Everyone's Souls, the *best* final boss music out of them all.
PQ>>>>P5>P3>P4
THIS CAROUSEEEEEEEL
P5 is fucking amazing imo
P4 has best non vocal tracks. P3 has dorm theme. And p5 has my
T H I C C thorax deep in Futaba's puss puss
Persona 5 has the best soundtrack for sure. P4 had some good ones too, but honestly I was never a big fan of a lot of songs in P3, they were just grating to me. Including the rest of the games, Persona 2's OST is pretty sweet but doesn't beat P5 or P4 for me, though I do love P1's OST as much as P4's. When I say I love P1's OST, I should specify I mean the PSP version. The PSX version is actual garbage.
Mm, that's hard. I definitely like Persona 3's moody tunes more than P4's; I think P4's OST is kind of too peppy for my tastes in comparison to the other games, though it still has a number of fantastic tracks.

Ultimately it's kind of a toss-up between P3 and P5. Both have the smooth jazz and the hype battle themes I dig.
Shin Megami Tensei Nocturne is still Shoji Meguro's best work :^)

Nah seriously though. P5 has a truly masterful OST, the Acid Jazz goes so perfectly with the stylish thief aesthetic, all the vocal tracks are beyond amazing and the battle themes are really great too.
P4's music almost had never more and i'll face myself's melodies in every song, so P3=P5's music for me. BABY, BABY, BABY, BABY, BABY, YEAHHHHH
Well.. i prefer P3 soundtrack, it's amazing xD But, P4 and P5 soundtrack is good too.
Persona 5 has beneath the mask, so P5 wins.
P4 has too many great dungeon soundtracks, while P5 has just two or three very awesome OSTs.
So I'd say P4>P5>P3, even though overall P5 could still be in the first place.
P4 is a beary awesome soundtrack (although I put p3 as my most favorite soundtrack and p4 in the second place)
I can't say really...I know P3 is at the bottom for me, because it just wasn't my jam.

Then P4 rolled around and won me over, and P5 did the same thing... so:

P5=P4 > P3
P5>P3>P4
(best: left to right)
P4, P5 then P3 (full ost)
P3, P4, P5 (ending song)
P4, P5 then P3(insert songs/ bgm)